John of John by Douglas Stuart
Filled with fierce drama of emotions repressed, concealed and delicately exposed, John of John, is a moody, atmospheric novel about the bonds of family and a young gay man trying to find his place in the world. The Plot Young John-Calum Macleod (Cal) is out of work and out of money after finishing art school on the mainland. Returning home to the island of Harris in the Outer Hebrides of Scotland, (original home of Harris Tweed, luxury handwoven cloth), Cal finds not much has changed. His father, John, a sheep farmer, weaver, and pillar of the local Presbyterian church and his grandmother, Ella, share an uneasy peace in a crofter house in a rugged isolated community. Cal and John are both disappointed in each other and in life. Cal is lonely and secretive about his sexuality. He tries desperately to connect with a neighbour boy who he once shared early fumbling teenage sex with. He ignores the attractive girl the community wants to see him wedded to. He scans gay want ads in urban newspapers trying to find a bond with someone. John is deeply religious, believing prayer and work to be not only salvation, but the answer to his own loneliness and to his shameful relationship with Innes, his long-time lover and neighbour. Despite his wife having left him years ago, he still lives in his wife’s croft house. He holds no rights to the tenancy but works the farm as though it’s his own and believes that one day it will be by virtue of that work. John is alarmed by his son’s long flaming hair, his lack of attraction to the local girls, and his unwillingness to be Saved by God. Ella, Cal’s maternal grandmother is the glue that holds the family together. After Cal’s mother left, she stayed on to raise him and now takes care of the house and of John despite their dislike for each other. John makes it plain Ella is not his responsibility, while Ella says the same. She refuses to learn Gaelic which is sprinkled throughout the book. Her refusal is a festering scab to John, but it also allows him to speak to Cal without Ella’s understanding. Or so he believes. Cal uneasily resumes his old life, determined to leave his father, but torn by the bonds of his community, his love for his mother, grandmother, and yes, even his father. As the threads that hold this fragile community together become entangled and the truth is gently revealed, everything changes. My Thoughts Stuart’s third, and finest novel yet, had me so gripped in his characters’ lives, I’d come to care for them as family. Each one is so tenderly written, they become someone you can picture sitting with while sharing a pot of tea. The novel is a reprise of the parable of the prodigal son and an ardent exploration of the half-lives of queer men condemned to love, pine and suffer in silence. Intimate, yet epic in scale, it contains equal parts pastoral drama, tale of familial fracture, love story and inquiry into various forms of loneliness: the loneliness that can reside between fathers and sons, between lovers, between man and God, and between a small place and the big world. Although I found the novel astonishing and deeply moving, there were times when the deceit and self-pity were draining. There was a desire to kick the characters into action, particularly young Cal, and a wish to see him board that ferry once and for all. As with Stuart’s previous novels, Shuggie Bain, and its follow-up Young Mungo, there is an overload of bleak, grimness. Many of the characters are doomed, but Stuart writes with a heartbreaking love for them and for this, I forgive much. There were also times when the novel seemed to drag on and I wondered if some scenes were necessary at all. But these are minor quibbles. While this book will not appeal to those with a low tolerance for excess, romantics will find much to love. Cal, John and Innes are knottily entangled and endearing and that is no small feat. The writing is beautiful with an emotional depth that brilliantly captures these imperfect characters and their hardscrabble landscape. Have you found some good books this fall you’d like to share? Tell me about them. And in the meantime, happy reading! Joni
0 Comments
|
Archives
October 2026
Categories |

RSS Feed